Brussels, 2 June 2022

Re: Urgent request to take into account the nature of a service for VLOPs determination in the DSA and to provide clarity on implementation timeline

Dear Mr. de Graaf,
Dear Mr. Agarwal,

We are writing to you in light of the finalisation of the Digital Services Act (DSA). Ecommerce Europe welcomes the agreement that has been reached and believes it will help reduce illegal content online and make the internet safer and more transparent. However, we remain concerned about the proposed definition of an ‘active recipient of the service’ and the suggested timeline for the implementation of the rules for Very Large Online Platforms (VLOPs).
The definition of active recipients is crucial for the DSA’s chapter on systemic risk management, in which specific obligations are introduced for VLOPs. Online platforms that reach a number of average monthly active recipients of the service of at least 45 million, can be designated as VLOPs. Recital 54 states that recipients of an online platform are those that engage with a service by clicking on, commenting, linking, sharing, purchasing or carrying out transactions on an online platform. Ecommerce Europe strongly supports that Recital 54 recognises that the determination of the number of active recipients can be impacted by market and technical developments. We welcome that the Commission “should be empowered to supplement the provisions of this Regulation by adopting delegating acts laying down the methodology to determine the active recipients of an online platform or search engine, where necessary, reflecting the nature of the service and the way recipients of the service interact with it.”
We are pleased with the reference to the need to potentially reflect the nature of the service and interaction as we believe the current definition is not appropriate to capture the ‘recipients’ of an e-commerce marketplace. E-commerce companies differentiate between ‘unique visitors’, individuals browsing through the website or app, and ‘active users’, referring to those users that have completed a transaction. This differentiation is important because in e-commerce, the number of visitors, who are merely window-shopping, is always much higher than the number of customers. If these market specifics are not taken into account, the consequence is that more transactional platforms will fall within the scope.
Additionally, we believe that an implementation period of “4 months from designation” is too short and leads to uncertainty if it comes into force earlier than the rest of the DSA, as it is likely that services will not be able to meet the implementation timeframe. It also remains unclear whether the intention is for this timing to be 6 months (to establish an average user figure) plus 3 months (to publish the figures) plus 4 months (from designation). Equally, it would create significant uncertainty if the Commission were to take the view that they could designate players without waiting for them to publish their first figures, further shortening the time for some services to implement some of the strictest obligations of the DSA. We strongly encourage the Commission to relieve significant uncertainty, whilst still achieving its stated position of applying the DSA to VLOPs earlier than to other services, by stating a date before which they will not designate VLOPs. We urge the Commission to prioritise and facilitate compliance by allowing businesses sufficient time to hire and train or retrain staff, redesign and implement new procedures, plan and execute technical changes in systems and deliver a stable and secure service for European consumers and sellers that will otherwise face unnecessary restrictions in their buying choices and their ability to reach customers at a time of already disrupted supply chains.
Finally, we are also concerned that for sellers and consumers using the services of VLOPs, the processes will not be in place on time within all Member States. This will create confusion, frustration and an unlevel playing field across the union. For example, Digital Service Coordinators may not have been established yet, or Alternative Dispute Resolution services to resolve disputes regarding notices may not yet be appointed. For sellers who have their offers removed or who believe that goods unfairly competing with them have not been removed, this is an important local service that already creates confusion with the P2B regulation, which is still not, or differently, implemented in some Member States.
To avoid placing a disproportionate burden on e-commerce marketplaces by considering them to be VLOPs based on the number of mere visitors, we call on the Commission to make use of the possibility to use delegated acts to tailor the definition of recipients to the service offered by an intermediary, taking in account the specifics of the different business models. Additionally, we stress the importance of allowing sufficient time to prepare for the designation.
We kindly request a meeting with you to further discuss and elaborate on our concerns.
We hope that you will take our suggestions into consideration, and we remain available for any questions you may have.
Thank you very much in advance for your consideration
Yours faithfully,

Luca Cassetti
Secretary General of Ecommerce Europe

Here you can download the Position Paper (PDF)

About Ecommerce Europe

Ecommerce Europe is the sole voice of the European Digital Commerce sector. As a result of joining forces with EMOTA, Ecommerce Europe now represents, via its 23 national associations, more than 100,000 companies selling goods and services online to consumers in Europe. Ecommerce Europe acts at European level to help legislators create a better framework for online merchants, so that their sales can grow further.

Website: www.ecommerce-europe.eu

Ecommerce Europe

ecommerce-europe.eu

Brussels Office

Rue d’Arlon 69-71
B-1040 Brussels (Belgium)

Tel.: +32 (0) 2 502 31 34
Monday-Friday 9:00 – 18:00 hrs (GMT+1)

Email: info@ecommerce-europe.eu

Column on the single VAT registration for Europe in the 23rd edition of Cross-Border Magazine

The President of Ecommerce Europe, Mr. Wijnand Jongen, contributed to the 23rd edition of Cross-Border Magazine with a column on the single VAT registration for Europe. Read it below and download the full magazine hereMore on LinkedInwww.ecommerce-europe.eu

U&we mit Angela

In Folge 9 von U&we stellen wir euch heute Angela vor. Angela ist Galeristin und vertritt super Künstler:innen wie Swen Kählert und Arnaldo Drés González (s. Bilder). In ihrer galerie holzhauer treffen viele unterschiedliche Kunststile aufeinander – das macht...

Zweiter Tag, Logistikreise des IDIH – Stationen 5, 6 und 7

2. Tag, Station 5, 6 und 7 der #Logistikreise vom IDIH - Institut des Interaktiven Handels GmbH: zuerst waren wir bei der MakroSolutions GmbH und haben einige Anwendungen zu fahrerlosen Transportsystemen und Ware zum Mann gesehen. Sehr spannend zu sehen, was alles...

The new DTC and retail Q-Commerce, with the same probability of success?

I do admire Brittain Ladd’s enthusiasm when reporting on new avenues in retail, but I believe this idea has more downsides than upsides. The upsides:Super convenient. I can get a bag of snacks and a sixpack in X minutes, from any of the brands around. OK, for lack of...

𝗥𝗲𝗳𝗼𝗿𝗺 𝗼𝗳 𝘁𝗵𝗲 𝗘𝗨 𝗰𝘂𝘀𝘁𝗼𝗺𝘀 𝗹𝗲𝗴𝗶𝘀𝗹𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 𝗮𝗻𝗱 𝗿𝗲𝗴𝘂𝗹𝗮𝘁𝗶𝗼𝗻 (𝗣𝗮𝗿𝘁 𝟮)

The #EU Customs Union is a #major cornerstone of the EU #SingleMarket and external #tradepolicy, and a #key component in the EU’s #strategic autonomy. Annex II of the EU #Commission Work Program 2022 foresees a revision of the Union Customs #legislation to meet the...

Byebye E-Commerce-Hype?

Ist der E-Commerce-Boom vorbei? 💥​❌​ Noch Anfang des Jahres verkündete der Bundesverband E-Commerce und Versandhandel Deutschland e.V. (bevh) aufgrund der explodierenden Umsätze in den Jahren 2020 und 2021, dass der E-Commerce das „New Normal“ sei. Doch jetzt machen...

L’e-commerce recule mais reste 20 % plus fort qu’avant le Covid

La fin de la crise sanitaire et de ses confinements fait reculer les ventes en ligne, de 17 % au deuxième trimestre 2022. Mais ce retour à la normale n'efface pas l'ensemble des gains. Dans tous les secteurs, l'activité sur le Net demeure bien au-dessus de ce qu'elle...

Contorion optimises dropshipping with Codept

Do you sell a niche product or products that require a lot of storage space (e.g. large seasonal items), do you not want to store all your goods or do you constantly expand your product assortment? There are a lot of reasons to choose dropshipping as a fulfilment...

BÄM-Camp der Wirtschaftsmacher

Nächsten Dienstag ist es schon so weit! 🤩 Dann startet das BÄM!-Camp der #Wirtschaftsmacher im House of Logistics and Mobility (HOLM) GmbH in #Frankfurt 🎇. Es warten reichlich Best Cases unserer Mitmacher und natürlich kommt auch der persönliche Austausch in...

Dritte und letzte Station für heute auf der Logistikreise von IDIH

3. und letzte Station für heute auf der Logistikreise von IDIH - Institut des Interaktiven Handels GmbH: Dennree. Die Erfolgsgeschichte von dennree GmbH ist recht beeindruckend. Am Standort #Töpen mit mittlerweile 94.000 m2 Fläche haben wir die eigene Bananenreifung...