The new DTC and retail Q-Commerce, with the same probability of success?

von | Sep. 26, 2022 | News, News Mitglieder

I do admire Brittain Ladd’s enthusiasm when reporting on new avenues in retail, but I believe this idea has more downsides than upsides.

The upsides:
Super convenient. I can get a bag of snacks and a sixpack in X minutes, from any of the brands around. OK, for lack of space it will probably only be the top selling products, but you can’t please all.

The brands will get the full turnover, with no retailer in between. That could be enough to finance the show, but will it increase profits? Setting up the Micro Fulfillment Centers (MFCs), get the fleet up and running, maintenance and so on, will not be cheap, not even at scale.

Retailers can put full supermarkets on wheels, but with a very limited number of SKUs. They will at least get higher utilization of the MFC structure they (probably) must establish for Food home delivery anyway. 

For brands it is rolling commercial, free product give-aways on the streets etc. I can see a lot of opportunities for advertising here. Retailers with their higher number of SKUs in the vehicles, will probably not be able to fully utilize the possibilities brands will have.

The downsides:
I like to do numbers, and here are numbers involved which kind of scares me. The number of these vehicles which could end up on our streets is staggering. If each brand, each retailer, the Starbucks and the like puts these Automato’es on the street, the traffic impact will by significant. And all those vehicles just to get a bag of snacks and a sixpack in X minutes? At least the Gorillas used bikes.
Worst case: A sixpack of a Coca Cola product and snacks from Pepsi? That is two vehicles per order.

Although automated, each vehicle will be cruising a lot, as delivery productivity (stops per hour) will be pretty low.

My conclusions
IMHO this is a continuation of q-commerce. Speed at any price, and disregarding basket size in relation to (financial) effort. 
The vehicles themselves, MFCs, repair shops, parking space and so on, will require a lot of expensive urban locations and all these investments just to support the ultra-fast delivery of a bag of snacks and a sixpack?
„Marketplace on Wheels“ as Brittain Ladd calls them, is not really a new idea, but it got killed due to limited product range (unattractive for consumers) and high cost (for the retailers).

I could see these vehicles doing deliveries for retailers (far bigger baskets), but only as same day delivery i.e., order before noon and get your goods in the afternoon. Would make a lot more sense, but then it is just another last mile delivery solution i.e., a rolling Click & Collect robot.

But then again, maybe I am just being old-fashioned!

More on LinkedIn

Pressemitteilung | logistic-natives e.V. – Mai 2025

Pressemitteilung Berlin, 24.05.2025 Der logistic-natives e.V. hat seinen Vorstand erweitert, sich personell erfolgreich für die aktuellen Herausforderungen aufgestellt & verstärkt seine Services Auf seiner diesjährigen Mitgliederversammlung hat der...

Single Market Strategy Report

Single Market Strategy Report REPORT May 2025 Ecommerce Europe has prepared a report on the Single Market Strategy, which includes an overview of the strategy, focusing on the parts relevant to the e-commerce sector. Each section provides a summary of the objectives...

Commission’s Strategy sets the right tone to strengthen the EU Single Market

Ecommerce Europe publishes Strategy Paper on the Circular Economy PRESS RELEASE 21 May 2025 Ecommerce Europe welcomes today’s publication of the European Single Market Strategy 2025. The Single Market is a cornerstone of the European economy as well as a unique...

Ecommerce Europe publishes Strategy Paper on the Circular Economy

Ecommerce Europe publishes Strategy Paper on the Circular Economy  PRESS RELEASE 30 April, 2025 Today, Ecommerce Europe published a comprehensive Strategy Paper, Closing the loop on the Circular Economy, laying out an ambitious vision and actionable recommendations to...

6. IDIH-Logistikreise – Mitte Juni 2025 von München bis nach Wien

Unser Mitglied IDIH geht wieder mit Euch auf Tour: Dieses Mal von München bis nach Wien vom 16. bis 18. Juni 2025. Wieder haben wir 8 spannende Besichtigungen „in den Rucksack gepackt“: Exotec Robotics ITG Kontraktlogistik LOCUS ROBOTICS BSH Hausgeräte Spar...

Wie wir wieder Weltspitze werden – 10 Punkte Programm

Wir brauchen eine Wirtschaftswende - jetzt.Dazu gehören folgende 10 Punkte: Bürokratieabbau Unternehmenssteuersenkung Sozialabgabenobergrenze Wettbewerbsfähige Energiepreise EU-Emissionshandel Flexibleres Arbeitsrecht Infrastruktur- und Dienstleistungsoffensive...

Aktionsbündnis Wirtschaftswarntag

Vor zwei Monaten haben die Unterzeichner gemeinsam mit insgesamt 140 Verbänden und Hunderten Unternehmen einen bundesweiten Wirtschaftswarntag organisiert mit rund 200 Aktionen in 100 Orten und mit fünf Kundgebungen. Die Wirtschaft demonstriert normalerweise nicht,...

Geld allein löst keine Standortprobleme – Strukturreformen jetzt!

Deutschland steht am Scheideweg. Immer mehr Menschen wenden sich extremistischen Gruppierungen zu. Mangelnde Verlässlichkeit politischer Entscheidungen, leere Versprechungen und eine Politik, die die konkreten Probleme der Bürgerinnen und Bürger in diesem Land nicht...

Joint statement on the enforcement of the Digital Markets Act (DMA)

Today, Ecommerce Europe, EuroCommerce, and Independent Retail Europe issued a joint statement calling on the Commission to swiftly advance its ongoing investigations and ensure timely enforcement of the Digital Markets Act (DMA) through balanced solutions which...

Gemeinsam für einen starken Mittelstand

Fahrplan für eine zukunftsfähige Wirtschaftspolitik 12-Punkte-Plan der Mittelstandsallianz des BVMW für die anstehenden Koalitionsverhandlungen und nächste Legislaturperiode. Fahrplan 2030:Was für den Mittelstand wichtig ist Wettbewerb Digitalisierung Arbeitsmarkt...